A Letter to a friend in a faith journey.....
I see your struggle. I hear your arguments. And I feel compelled to write how I see it, and I hope to encourage you to keep going. These are a bunch of my random thoughts. Hopefully, it may make sense to you as I share my heart…
I am a member of the church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints because here I find Light and Truth. When I find more light and truth outside of the church, I’m excited to learn about it. But this church is my home base.
Here’s the truth: You just get to decide what you want to believe. Who do you want to be and what you want your life and your family’s life to look like?
I’ve tried at times to be a non-believer, and I like myself more as a believer…I believe in the spiritual, heavenly angels and tender mercies. It’s fun to be a believer and NOT have all the answers. I didn’t always feel this way…But I do now. Being a believer or a non-believer both take a leap of faith.
We will never be able to prove that the Church is true or false beyond a reasonable doubt. For every critic who has some complaint about church history, or BoM, there is a pretty good answer or some evidence and a counter-narrative that shows the opposite…and vice versa.
AND that’s how it’s supposed to be. It’s called Faith. You just get to decide.
There’s always going to be a gap.
There is a scale of doubt and belief. The scale can shift either way…some things on my doubt scale have been solved, and now it’s on my belief side….. or some things I believed, now I doubt, but I can do this IN the church, I don’t have to leave to do this. We don’t need to hang so tightly onto our own opinions. Things change…ebb and flow.
I say “maybe” a lot. I don’t really know and you don’t really know either…..so it’s a maybe. We have a culture in the church of saying, “I know….” But where’s the Faith in that?
“I don’t know much, but I choose to believe this is God’s church and Jesus is my Savior.”
Giving up on I know statements and trading in for I believe ones feels freeing and liberating.
How the mind works… We are not our thoughts! Our thoughts occur in our brain, and we can observe what’s going on there. We are the thinkers, the contributors at times, but thoughts are not us.
( The deeper self/soul is who we are. We are every age we have ever been. Our true self lives on and is eternal. Another discussion for another day.)
You can think whatever you want to think.
People have always dismissed or left the church…. And people continue to join or stay in the church. You get to decide.
I’ve heard it taught this way……as a member of the church, you have gospel exclamation points- spiritual experiences, priesthood blessings, Book of Mormon is true….. And also gospel questions like… I don’t agree with polygamy and have some problems with church history or what Brigham Young said about race and the LGBTQ stance. When you start to struggle with the church, your exclamation points become polygamy, Brigham Young, church history, LGBTQ … and you question your spiritual experiences, priesthood blessings, Book of Mormon and testimony. It totally flips.
At this point we often Maximize voices out of the church… and minimize church narratives. Was Joseph Smith a prophet? What about polygamy? All the critics are saying the “right” things, and people in the church are saying the “wrong” things. You start to form a new narrative, which then leads you out.
Your lens changes over time…..(depending on who you hang out with, what you listen to, what you fill your brain with, how you spend your time.)
It feels like the curtain has been pulled back and you see the wizard of oz for who he is…. but all of these are just thoughts.
In deciding about polygamy and Joseph Smith, Brigham Young etc is when Paradox comes into play….. we can learn to hold two things in contradiction. We can live in dissonance. We can have competing narratives. Joseph Smith and polygamy are difficult for me, and I don’t agree with this practice and Joseph Smith brought forth the Book of Mormon, which teaches truth and strengthens my testimony of Jesus Christ. (The brain doesn’t like dissonance because it likes things to be simple. It thinks you are in danger. There is no danger here. Talk to your brain and remind it you are safe. )
Buddha said, ”The deepest truth isn’t understood by the rational mind.” And as I ask questions I can see how this is true.
So what keeps me here? What are my exclamation points?
The Book of Mormon. I believe in its divine origins and it speaks truth to me.
My belief in a Heavenly Mother that only this church speaks of ( although minimally, but she’s in the temple!)
Priesthood blessings and remembering spiritual experiences that are tied into this. ( Stephi, Laila, Laura)
Being challenged and loved by a ward family who are also striving to be Christ-like.
Having a living Prophet over a Living church, that continues to be restored, so changes can and do happen.
Traditions of my mother and father and grandparents who all led stellar lives!
I just decided.
I now see myself as a nuanced church member. I accept some things and I don’t others…and I’m okay with that. And I feel God is okay with that, too. HE sees me and knows my heart. I find great comfort in this. I find people who stay, who are on the margins of the church, have a more open, fluid way of thinking about things, and are easier to talk and relate to. This is my role now for others. I can hear and try to understand…and find it fascinating, and interesting…and maybe they’re right, and maybe they’re not. None of this threatens my testimony.
I believe the Holy Spirit is my teacher and it’s good to ask hard questions and grapple with things. Some questions’ answers require more life experience, some take time, some require learning something I didn’t know before. I’m not in a hurry for answers. Now I let the spirit guide and don’t hold so fast to my own opinions.
It’s not a faith crisis. There’s no rush.. It’s not a crisis. The house is not on fire. Life is a journey….and this is all part of it. We get to ask challenging questions and learn and explore.
You have plenty of time to figure this out. Keep searching. Talk to your thoughts, don’t just listen to them. Lean into the spirit.
I hope we can continue this discussion as we learn and grow together.
P.S. If I could suggest one change, it would be to listen to a chapter of the Book of Mormon every day. I listen first thing in the morning. Some days I get something out of it, most days, not much, but I rely on this habit because I want to stay.